The Red Winter by Cameron Sullivan is a 535 page novel published by Tor Books in 2025.

Genre

Historical Fantasy

My Thoughts

What do I think? Let’s see. In less than a minute on the job, you’ve fallen foul of the bishop, got involved with some fancy twit and attracted the attention of a man with the biggest gun I’ve ever seen…Even for you, this is remarkable! That’s what I think.

I loved a lot about this historical fantasy imagining of the real story behind the Beast of Gévaudan, the man-eating animal that terrorized a region of France over a period of years in the late eighteenth century (there are several other works of fiction based off of this part of history, and the one that comes to mind foremost for me is the movie Brotherhood of the Wolf). It’s dark and bloody, it’s got elements of mythology and the paranormal, and it features a doomed queer romance.

The main character, Professor Sebastian Grave, has lived for centuries hosting a Spirit (it’s considered uncouth to use the phrase “possessed by”) called Sarmodel. This book is Sebastian relaying the story of the time a young nobleman called him back to Gévaudan for a contract unfulfilled. As the two travel there together, Sebastian in turn tells him the story of when he first signed the contract some twenty years before. He, among many others, had answered the call of the king of France to hunt down the Beast that had been slaughtering livestock and citizens alike. During this time, Sebastian had carried on a love affair with the nobleman’s father, and shared some of the secrets of his true nature with the man. A couple of decades later, the slaughter has begun anew; it seems the Beast may be back, and the professor practiced in the Arcane arts may be their best hope.

If you’re on board so far for the grisly werewolf origin story, know that this is the kind of novel that involves footnotes – I understand this is a big turn off for some readers, but it tends to really work for me. Here the footnotes are not overused, are often employed to explain some Arcane aspect of the book’s universe, and are occasionally laugh out loud funny. Some of the inner-dialogue between Sebastian and Sarmodel also provide moments of humor, as do the interspersed addendums written by Livia, the succubus bound to Sebastian’s service. (These portions of story reflect back on a period in fifteenth century France, when our protagonist first finds himself up against the figure behind the Beast – and so another thing to know before deciding if this book is right for you is that it does alternate among multiple timelines.)

I do think this story crammed in an awful lot: demons, Archangels, Greek mythology, sorcery, werewolves, Joan of Arc, romance, the French Revolution. I personally enjoyed each of these aspects, but I do feel that the book failed to fully manage to pull it all together into a cohesive whole that 100% satisfied me. Between that and the fact that it felt a bit overly long, I would rate this 4.5 stars in a system that allows for half stars (or even 4.75 if we were going with quarter stars). That’s still fabulous, of course!

In the Acknowledgments section, the author implies that this might in fact be only one book in a potential series of adventures had by Sebastian, Sarmodel and Livia. Considering they’ve had centuries of them, I am curious to see what the next story will be about!