Those Fatal Flowers by Shannon Ives is a 384 page standalone novel from Dell of Ballantine Books with a publish date of January 21, 2025.
Genre/Subgenres:
Mythology Retelling, Historical Fiction, Romance
Opening Line:
The night before Ceres’ palace becomes a tomb, it’s halls are filled with music.
Synopsis:
Greco-Roman mythology and the mystery of the vanished Roanoke colony collide in this epic adventure filled with sapphic longing and female rage—a debut novel for fans of Madeline Miller, Jennifer Saint, and Natalie Haynes.Before, Scopuli.
It has been centuries since Thelia made the mistake that cost her the woman she loved. As the handmaidens charged with protecting Proserpina, the goddess of spring, Thelia and her sisters are banished to the island of Scopuli, cursed to live as sirens—winged half-woman, half-bird creatures. In luring men to their death, they hope to gain favor from the gods who could free them. But then ships stop coming and Thelia fears a fate worse than the underworld. Just as time begins to run out, a voice emerges, Proserpina’s voice; and what she asks of Thelia will spark a daring and dangerous quest for freedom.
Now, Roanoke.
Thelia can’t bear to reflect on her last moments in Scopuli, where she left behind her sisters. After weeks drifting at sea, Thelia’s renewed human body is close to death. Luckily, an unfamiliar island appears on the horizon—Roanoke. Posing as a princess arriving on a sailboat filled with riches, Thelia infiltrates the small English colony. It doesn’t take long for her to realize that this place is dangerous, especially for women. As she grows closer to a beautiful settler who mysteriously resembles her former love, Thelia formulates a plan to save her sisters and enact revenge on the violent men she’s come to hate. But is she willing to go back to Scopuli and face the decisions of her past? And will Proserpina forgive her for all that she’s done?Told in alternating timelines, Those Fatal Flowers is a powerful, passionate, and wildly cathartic love letter to femininity and the monstrous power within us all.
My Thoughts:
What happens when you mix a mystery from America’s history with mythology, feminist rage, and romance?
This book right here.
It presents an interesting case: what if sirens from Greco-Roman mythology were responsible for the disappearance of the inhabitants of the lost colony of Roanoke? The author explains that her aim with this story was to explore the effects of loss and guilt on the psyche while also examining structural violence. It does a fair job in this endeavor, while also including a sapphic love story.
Our main character is Thelia, one of three sisters who acted as handmaidens to Proserpina (Persephone), and who were transformed into winged creatures to assist in the search for their charge when she was abducted by Dis (Hades). When they fail to find and rescue the goddess, they are imprisoned on an island as punishment. There, they lure sailors with their singing. (This book alternately refers to them as harpies and sirens, but I think the singing and luring part indicates they were just sirens, not harpies?)
After centuries have gone by, Thelia learns there may be a way to lift the curse she and her sisters are under, but it requires the sacrifice of many treacherous men…something the English colony of Roanoke in the Americas has more then a few of.
I liked the unique premise of the story and the bits detailing the lives of Thelia and her sister sirens on the island of Scopuli, and the writing on the sentence level was good.
On the other hand, I questioned the reliability of the behavior and speech of the Puritans depicted here. The men and women of Raleigh drank an awful lot of alcohol in this book, and said things like, “Fun little secret for you, my lady” before revealing some bit of gossip. I’m no scholar of history, but these things didn’t seem right to me. And I just wasn’t much feeling the romance — it was a bit of instalove on Thelia’s side (although in part because the object of her affections apparently looks so much like her long lost love that for a time she is trying to determine if it might actually BE her); and also, when on a timed mission for redemption, shouldn’t a centuries old divinity be able to keep it in her skirts?
All the hate for anything male really bothered me, BUT this does get addressed later on in the book, as Thelia finally learns that “monsters are made, not born”.
So while this book wasn’t a home run for me, it was decent and presents some intriguing concepts. If I were allowed half or even quarter star ratings, I’d say this was a 3.25 or 3.5 read for me.
Thank you the NetGalley and Dell/Penguin Random House for the eARC in exchange for my honest review!
I wrote this short story for consideration for inclusion in an anthology about Morgana le Fey. Alas, it was not accepted, but I am quite fond of it and so decided to share it here. Let me know your thoughts!
I opted to write about a version of Morgana as described by Geoffrey of Monmouth in his narrative poem, Vita Merlini, which was published in 1155 AD and was the enchanting figure’s first appearance in literature that is currently recognized. Her name is given as Morgen in that work, and so that is how I chose to refer to her in my story.
The sea swells and surges up the shores of Avalon. The swash rises through the air in a spinning rush of water, forming an aqueous column that coalesces into the form of a naked woman. The figure solidifies in a gradual progression from the bottoms of her bare feet to her water darkened tresses.
Morgen has returned home.
Her sisters have been awaiting her arrival. Glitonea, taking her turn as lookout, approaches with a robe held open before her. “What word?” she asks as she wraps the garment about her eldest sister’s shoulders, which are glistening with water droplets and adorned with gooseflesh.
Her lips pressed into a thin line, Morgen looks to Glitonea and gives a bare shake of her head. The news is grim.
But she is surprised to see that beyond a brief furrowing of the brow, her sister does not seem as dismayed as she might. Morgen realizes that the Glitonea is harboring news of her own, and it is something that has her excited. She waits for the other woman’s storm colored eyes to meet her own.
“What is it?”
“Men have come to the island.” The words are expelled in a rush.
“Men?”
“Mortals.”
Buffeted by the bracing sea air, Morgen pulls the ends of the robe tightly around her body and gazes up at the tor that juts up from the coastline while considering this news. After a moment, the two women begin the trek up the cliffside path to the keep, the home they share with their seven other sisters. Glitonea soon breaks the silence.
“Did you really find nothing?” she asks in a faint voice.
Morgen did not find nothing. Her travels through the seas took her to Greece, where she found a dragon with no less than one hundred heads thwarting her efforts to seek a meeting with the Daughters of the Evening. She found waters in Europe that restored sight, waters that drove its drinkers mad or bestowed great strength. She had been soaring over yellowed plains when through the air came to her an albatross’s cry resonating in such torment that her own wings missed a beat and her heart dropped in her breast. She had encountered a species of bird that brings forth life through the shedding of its own blood, a sacrificial offering of balance.
What Morgen did not find was an answer to how to stop the golden apple tree at the center of Avalon from continuing to wither and die, and with it the island’s magic.
The boons of the Fortunate Isle are tied to that singular tree with its resplendent fruit. Its roots feed enchantment into the soil, sending its gifts outward through its communion with the rest of the land. It is thanks to this tree that Avalon is so fruitful of its own account, without need of plough or toil. For its devoted inhabitants, the land provides without fail the fruit and grains that feed them and the herbs they use in their healing balms, unguents and tonics. It is the exceptional nature of the place that grants the sisters that call it home the alacrity and ease with which they have been able to focus and enhance their spellwork. Their conjurations are threefold as strong as they would otherwise be.
And now it all decays. Over the past months an insidious rot has taken hold, the effects of which have been subtle as of yet, but worrisome all the same.
“Nothing of use. At least not that I can see,” Morgen answers. As they climb the wooden steps to the elevated entrance of the keep, she says, “Tell me of these men.”
Glitonea obliges gladly. “At first we thought it was just three of them, two warriors in hauberks and a man dressed like a bard, all ferried by Barinthus on his barge. But as they came ashore we saw there was another man, wounded, laid out on the deck.”
“You offered healing?” Morgen asks. What she really means is, were you able to heal the man, or have your abilities deteriorated even too far for that?
A look of consternation steals over Glitonea’s face as she explains, “We each of us tried. But you have always been the most skillful healer among us. Perhaps you will succeed where we have not.” Then, somberly, “It is a most grievous wound.”
Crossing through the eastern solar of their home Morgen sees more of her sisters, some alone and others arranged in groups. Save for Thitis, who is drawing doleful music from a cither, her favored instrument that she has not found the will to take up much in the past months, they appear to stand or lounge around purposelessly. They have been thrown from their routine with the arrival of strangers and do not know quite what to do with themselves. One of them lets escape a titter and Morgen glances over her shoulder to look for the source. Moronoe and Tyronoe are leaned in close conversation with one another before a tapestry depicting a stag posed within a ring of hazel trees. The former holds a hand clasped over her mouth. It is unsurprising to Morgen that those two, despite the grave manner of the men’s visit, would yet be delighted by their presence. The opportunity for social exchange outside of their circle appeals to many of the women, of course, but there are those who are especially enamored with the potential for commerce of the sexes. There are also those who will have been disappointed that the ferryman had not brought them fresh female company.
As she exits the room and approaches the keep’s central staircase, Morgen tells Glitonea, “I will go to my chamber to dress. Then I will see to these men.”
Standing in her bed chamber and dressed now in a sleeved undergarment, Morgen plaits the damp tangle of her hair with a deft hand. She slips into a dark green peplos, fastening it at the shoulders with brooches. All the while her mind is a churning maelstrom.
There had been seasons of Morgen’s life when mortals coming ashore would have appealed to her foremost as an opportunity for exercises in love. Such activities held little interest for her these days, and not only because she has tired of partners scorning their beloved the moment they grow bored, all lovers feeling jilted in the end. If one of the paramours is skilled in enchantment, well, the accusations flung become all the more absurd.
But now. The golden apple tree waning for the first time since the sisters had made the island their home decades before, and Avalon’s magic with it. The ill portent of the albatross’s lament. And now the arrival of mortals. What did it all mean? Had she missed some sign writ in the stars? Had her skills reading the heavens diminished so much?
From the cabinet beside her bed, Morgen pulls out a corded belt to cinch around her waist. From one side she hangs a pouch of herbs, from the other a ceremonial blade in its leather sheath. Before shutting the cupboard door, something catches her eye. On the floor, half hidden behind her slippers, is the drinking horn she had once spelled. The charm she laid over the instrument was designed to reveal infidelity by causing any unfaithful lover who attempted to drink from it to spill its contents without a single drop passing his or her lips. For many days and nights she had struggled to perfect the magic. Finally, she learned that in order to force a person’s secrets into the open in this way required her to divulge one of her own. Only after speaking her greatest shame into the mouth of the vessel would it perform as intended. This took further consideration on her part, as Morgen is a woman who does not involve herself overmuch with the concept of shame. Just as she feels an entirely changed being from the one she was at the time of the horn’s creation, she feels no antagonism for that woman of the past; some of her actions may have been misguided, but her feelings then were just as valid as her desire to restore Avalon’s glory now.
Toeing the horn further to the back of the cabinet, she shuts the door and goes to see about healing a wounded man.
The prostrate form has been laid out atop the golden coverlet over Tyronoe’s bed. His chain mail and greaves have been removed, leaving him stripped down to tunic and breeches. His brow is furrowed and his mouth twisted in a grimace, but his eyes remain closed; he has withdrawn into himself. Blood-covered hands are crossed gingerly over the black stain spread over his abdomen, an unconscious guarding of a wound that draws the eye like a baleful storm cloud on the horizon.
Arrayed around the bed are those who accompanied the injured man to the island as Glitonea has relayed. One of the soldiers has yellow curls, the other brazen eyebrows and a beard halfway to gray. The bard doffs his cap and falls to his knees before Morgen where she stands next to Glitonea just inside the threshold.
“Great Lady! I am called Taliesin. These good men of Caerleon are of the king’s retinue. You, Lady, are renowned across the lands for your great skill in healing ailments of all kinds, your talents said to be matched only by your wisdom and beauty. We come to beseech you: please, do what you can to save the life of the Benevolent and Wise King Arthur!”
Halfway during this speech, Morgen had returned her eyes to the figure on the bed. The man Taliesin remains kneeling on the floor as he awaits her response. Morgen turns her head slightly in her sister’s direction and speaks in a soft undertone. “You did not say he was a king.”
“Does it matter?”
Morgen crosses the room in measured steps, approaching the bed. “How did he sustain this injury?” she asks. The bard struggles off his knees to stand behind her.
“Run through with a sword wielded by his own nephew,” the younger of the soldiers answers. He glares through his curling locks as he speaks these words, but Morgen knows his animosity is directed at this nephew, not at her.
Stopping at the bedside, she continues to assess the sight before her. The muscles of the king’s throat work as he labors to swallow what moisture his body is able to muster, eyes still screwed shut. Eventually she shifts her scrutiny down toward the gash in his belly. She begins to reach a gentle hand toward laceration when she is surprised to find the man’s own suddenly gripping her wrist, more strength in his hold than she would have thought he was capable of summoning in his current state.
She looks up and finds his eyes open and staring into hers. She notices they are green.
Silence commands the room for several long moments while they observe one another. Finally one of his soldiers ventures, “My Lord King?” Arthur’s grip loosens until he eventually drops his hand to his side, but his eyes remain open. He does not speak.
Morgen returns her attention to the wound. It is not a clean cut, but jagged as though his opponent had wrenched the steel in a twisting motion before tugging it free. It seems a cruel act born of a singular enmity. She lets her fingers hover over the rent in the flesh and extends her senses, confirming what she has already begun to suspect.
It is too late to save this man. The injury is a grievous one, yes, but his body’s reaction to the insult has passed the point of reversal, birthing a cascade of further catastrophes throughout his systems, setting a multitude of fires that cannot all be doused before he succumbs. Looking at the man’s face, Morgen sees he has shut his eyes once more, and notices now the gray shadow that has begun to tint his skin. She imagines he does not have much time left.
To the side of this throat she can see the fluttering of a pulse, the blood yet coursing through his veins, albeit more feebly than usual. The blood of a king. The eddies within Morgen’s mind swirl with a new turbulence as she considers this.
“I have heard of you, Arthur of Pendragon,” she says. She believes he can still hear her, though he makes no response. “You are known to have united the peoples of your land. It is said you champion equality among your advisors, allowing no unfair advantages due to birth or other circumstances left to fate alone. You treat all persons with respect without requiring them to earn it, but rather allowing them the agency to lose it by their own efforts. You have been found worthy across varying fields. You, Arthur, are a Great King.”
She hears one of the other men choke back an expression of grief. It does not do to weep or otherwise conspicuously convey sorrow before a death has occurred, as it may draw the attention of forces from the Otherworld that would only hasten that outcome, even if it had not been an inevitability.
Morgen takes a moment to arrange her face before lifting it to address Taliesin. “You must leave him here with us. His recovery is not a thing that can be managed in a short time.”
It is as though a flame has been lit within the bard, the way his face lights up at these words. “You can heal him, then!” he cries. Morgen makes no answer. “Yes, yes, we will leave him in your capable hands, Lady. Your divinely appointed skills cannot be rushed, we understand! No motte and bailey is raised in a single day.”
Morgen nods and then resumes her position next to her sister. They watch as the men huddled around the recumbent form in the bed, taking their leave of their lord and speaking their reassurances and pledges to him. The women see tears of relief upon the younger soldier’s cheek. They and several other of their sisters walk the men down to the beach, where Barinthus is already waiting with his barge, as he is always aware when his services are needed. The bard continues to effuse gratitude and praise even as the vessel pushes off from shore.
Some of the women pull away and return to the keep. Morgen and Glitonea remain the longest, watching the forms of the departing mortals recede along the bobbing waves.
“You let them believe we would heal him,” Glitonea remarks after several long moments.
Morgen swipes away strands of hair that the wind blown in off the sea has stuck to her lips. “They heard what they wanted to hear,” she demurs.
“What you wanted them to hear,” Glitonea amends. Morgen makes a swift tilt of her head as if to say: these things are the same. “What is it you are planning?”
Looking her sister full in the face, Morgen explains. “You asked if it mattered that he is a king. In calling himself a king, a man dons a mantle of importance like a cloak, granting himself a significance that may not have been there before. This consequence goes beyond surface level. He is changed in ways he may not have anticipated.”
Glitonea stares out to sea, considering these words. In time, Morgen says, “Help me gather the others. We will need a litter to convey him.”
The nine sisters stand in Avalon’s central grove, arrayed around a dying man laid beside an apple tree. The tree is also dying.
The browned edges of shriveled leaves curl inward. The golden fruit is wrinkled and dull. Usually while standing in this orchard there can be heard a low, sonorous tone that seems to originate in the earth itself. Always faint, the sound is now nearly imperceptible.
Thitis kneels on the ground with the man’s head and shoulders laid in her lap, holding him tilted slightly so that he is angled toward the tree. Had he been aware of his surroundings, perhaps a hope that the women were about to feed him one of the golden apples said to grant immortality would have flared within his chest. Yet he is heedless. Before transferring him to the litter to bring him to the tree, Morgen had tipped one of her draughts into his slackened mouth and induced him to swallow. His brow had soon smoothed and he now slept the peaceful sleep of the untroubled, pain nothing more than a bad dream from which he had moved on to sweeter visions. It was not his suffering Morgen sought; she was not a monster. In fact, she found herself wishing for a moment that she had had the chance to meet the man before fate had come calling on him. Her words before had been sincere. The deeds he was known for were mostly cause for great admiration, although ruling a kingdom was never a bloodless endeavor.
They would drop his armor into the sea, after, as an offering, and in supplication for his safe passage to the Otherworld.
Morgen lowers herself to her knees before him.
“Sisters,” she calls out. “For decades the magic of Avalon, spawned from this very spot, has provided life to the island. Sustenance. Restoration. Knowledge and guidance. But in all things, there must be a balance. The magic is owed its due. What can we offer as equipoise for these gifts?” She looked at the others, all standing with their heads held high, except for the kneeling Thitis, who stroked the man’s hair. Morgen slid her blade from its sheath on her belt and answered her own question. “We offer the death of a king!”
In one sure motion, Morgen glides her blade in between King Arthur’s ribs and upward into his heart. She withdraws it and Thitis tilts him further, so that his heart’s blood pumps directly onto the earth housing the tree’s roots.
The women all begin wailing, their keening sending birds from the surrounding foliage into startled flight, as the golden apple tree unfurls verdant leaves, its fruit plumpens and gleams, and the earth sings.
The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst is a 384 page standalone novel published in 2024. (I saw it labeled as “Librarians of Alyssium #1” somewhere, but I can’t find where – but either way, this story can stand by itself.)
Genre:
Fantasy
Subgenres:
Cozy Fantasy, Romantasy, Romance
Opening Line
Kiela never thought the flames would reach the library.
My Thoughts
When revolution makes the city of Alyssium a dangerous place to be, librarian Kiela and her sentient spider plant assistant flee to the outer island of Caltrey. There they meet caring neighbors, winged cats, merhorses, and more, while also growing their own ingredients to make and sell jam. If anyone from the city ever learns that Kiela is illegally using spells to heal the island’s ecosystem, there could be dire consequences. Also there is a gentle romance.
This book was intended to be like a warm hug, eliciting the coziness of drinking hot cocoa and eating pastries. In this regard, it is a success. My preferred reads tend to be darker, grittier, and more dramatic, so based purely on my personal enjoyment I would say this was a 3 star read. But I knew to expect a warm cozy fantasy with sweet relationships, and that’s exactly what I got, so taking that into account it’s a 4.
Voyage of the Damned by Frances White is a standalone debut novel published in 2024.
Genre:
Fantasy
Subgenres:
Young Adult, Queer Romance, Murder Mystery
Opening Line:
My father always said: ‘You can’t run from your responsibilities,’ but he lacks imagination.
My Thoughts:
Confession: I bought this book solely because of how pretty it was.
Now that VOYAGE OF THE DAMNED by Frances White is a nominee in two categories of the 2024 Goodreads Choice Awards, I picked it up from my TBR stack. For the first chapter or two, I didn’t think it was going to be my jam, but I did wind up enjoying it quite a bit for what it was.
This book is YA Gideon the Ninth.
The young scions of each of the twelve provinces of the empire of Concordia are stuck on a ship with one another when they start dying mysteriously one by one. Each of them has their own special power (Blessing), as well as a hair and eye color based on their province (i.e. all people from Ox Province have red hair and red eyes, while everyone from Tiger Province has blue hair, etc.). The super snarky underdog queer main character has to figure out what’s really going on in this locked room murder mystery with magic.
This book thinks it is adult (and it is a nominee in the Fantasy category of the Goodreads Choice Awards, not Young Adult Fantasy), and so there are F-bombs and other curse words sprinkled throughout, plus plenty of sexual innuendo. But the tone and writing style were very young adult. I thought the main character was a teenager, until a good while in he tells someone he is twenty-two and a quarter. You know who describes their age using quarters? Children. All of the other characters are of a similar age and act pretty young.
The worldbuilding does not stand up to any amount of scrutiny whatsoever. But as long as you’re willing to just take it at its word and enjoy the ride, this is a fun story with lots of magic and murder, and a queer romance to boot. And that’s just what I was able to do – not question things too much, and have a good time!
Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West by Gregory Maguire is 406 page novel published in 1995 by ReganBooks, and is the first in The Wicked Years series.
Genre:
Fantasy, Retelling
Opening Line:
A mile above Oz, the Witch balanced on the wind’s forward edge, as if she were a green fleck of the land itself, flung up and sent wheeling by the turbulent air.
My Thoughts:
Oh, this book–I wanted to live in its pages forever!
I can certainly see how this book would not be every reader’s cup of tea. It is not a fast paced, action packed, plot driven narrative. The writing is very literary in style as readers are planted in the world of Oz and learn of its cultures, religions, and politics through the lens of one woman’s life story. But the writing is also absurd and humorous at times, surprising laughs out of me when I wasn’t expecting them. The five Parts of the story follow different eras of Elphaba’s life, each section taking place several years after the previous one. Through her life story we confront questions of morality, faith, and philosophy. And though it fell apart a bit at the end for me and left me with many questions, I loved every minute of my time spent in Maguire’s Oz! (To be clear, I definitely would not want to LITERALLY spend time there.)
In Part I, Munchkinlanders, we meet Elphaba’s parents: Frex, the unionist minister, and Melena, often left alone at their remote cottage to console herself with mind-altering substances. Frex is on a mission to preach against tiktokism and the pleasure faith that is becoming more popular when Melena gives birth to their first child, who is born shockingly green of skin and with razor sharp teeth (and because the author seems to be rather fixated on male genitalia in this first part of the book, she is born with “a bit of organic effluvia” or something in her groin that makes the midwives argue at first over whether the infant is a boy or a girl). She also avoids water at all costs, as it seems to pain her. Frex and Melena believe this child is meant as a punishment for them, or perhaps that she is possessed by some devil.
Perhaps, thought Nanny, little green Elphaba chose her own sex, and her own color, and to hell with her parents.
When Melena is expecting again, she faithfully takes capsules provided by Yackle, a crone at an alchemy shop, to try to prevent a recurrence of the defects of her first child (instead, little Nessarose is born without arms). In the reading of tea leaves, Yackle predicts greatness for Melena’s children, two sisters.
“She said history waits to be written, and this family has a part in it.”
In this part of the story we also get introduced to the Quadlings of southern Oz, as Frex and Melena befriend a foreigner named Turtle Heart. Quadlings seem to be seers of some sort, and to be the only residents of Oz who are aware of our/Dorothy’s world. Quadling Country is swampy land where the people build their homes in the trees, connected by platforms secured with ropes. Workers from the Emerald City have begun to build dikes and divide the land into parcels that will no longer be self-sustainable, and then they find the land is rich in rubies. The Quadlings have foreseen a cruel and mighty stranger king arriving in Oz via hot air balloon, exterminating them in order to pillage their land for its riches. Frex decides this means the population down south are more in need of his ministrations, and he sets off with his pregnant wife, toddler daughter, and Quadling friend in tow.
“She is herself pleased at the half things,” Turtle Heart said. “I think. The little girl to play with the broken pieces better.”
In Part II, Gillikin, 17 year old Elphaba is off to university. She winds up befriending her pretty roommate, Galinda, which could not be more of a surprise to either of them.
Galinda was slow coming to terms with actual learning. She had considered her admission to Shiz University as a sort of testimony to her brilliance, and believed that she would adorn the halls of learning with her beauty and occasional clever sayings. She supposed, glumly, that she had meant to be a sort of living marble bust: This is Youthful Intelligence; admire Her. Isn’t She lovely?
Galinda does not understand why Elphaba spends so much time reading old sermons about the nature of good and evil. Pagans of yore believed evil originated with the vacuum created when the Fairy Queen Lurline, who they considered to be the the creator of Oz, left them: “When goodness removes itself, the space it occupies corrodes and becomes evil, and maybe splits apart and multiplies. So every evil thing is a sign of the absence of deity.” But the early unionists argued evil was an invisible pocket of corruption floating around, “a direct descendant of the pain the world felt when Lurline left”, and anyone might pass through it and become infected with evil by no fault of their own.
“But they believe in evil still,” said Galinda with a yawn. “Isn’t that funny, that deity is passe but the attributes and implications of deity linger-“
“You are thinking!” Elphaba cried.
During her time at this institution of higher learning, Elphaba becomes aware of the growing discrimination, encouraged by the laws passed by the Wizard of Oz who had usurped the Ozma Regent years before, against Animals (anthropomorphized, sentient and speaking versions of lower case A animals). One of their professors, Doctor Dillamond, is a Goat researching the biological basis for what makes an animal different from an Animal and from a human, to disprove that Animals are lesser and stop the inhumane treatment of those who had, up until the arrival of the Wizard, been considered equal members of society. It is during this time in her life that Elphaba learns her righteous indignity, a spirit of activism, and her derision for political machinations. This part of the story includes a murder, and a bid to recruit Elphaba, Glinda (who has changed her name for reasons I can’t explain without spoilers), and Nessarose into the service of the despotic Wizard. His Oz is “a seething volcano threatening to erupt and burn us in its own poisonous pus”, with “communities on edge, ethnic groups against one another, bankers against farmers and factories against shopkeepers”. The one attempting the recruiting assures Elphaba she can harness her spirit and she “needn’t live a life of unfulfilled rage”.
Also, an old woman named Yackle works selling tickets at some questionable sex club.
In Part III, City of Emeralds, we see Elphaba’s time as a secret agent, an underground activist. It is also when she carries out a romance with Fiyero, and I find I have to comment on his character here. I have never seen the Wicked musical, but I see that in the upcoming version, Fiyero is played by Jonathan Bailey, who seems lovely. I am a bit confused by this casting, though, as the character of Fiyero is an Arjiki prince from the Vinkus to the far west, a dark-skinned man with blue diamond tribal tattoos over his entire body. He is described as dark-skinned multiple times, ochre-skinned, and one character observes that his skin is the color of shit (this book is all about prejudice and discrimination in “civilized” society.) So why is he played by a white dude?
Also, Fiyero is kind of the worst. All he does is patently disregard and disrespect all of Elphaba’s clearly expressed wishes, so I don’t understand the romance between them at all. But he does allow for conversations with Elphaba about the ethics of her righteous campaign and the eschewing of personal responsibility for any collateral damage. There is talk of terrorists hiding behind their ideals, and when questioned about the chance for innocent bystanders to be caught in the crossfire, Elphaba goes so far as to say, “Any casualty of the struggle is their fault, not ours.” This is also when we first hear about Elphaba questioning the existence of souls, and that she certainly does not believe that she herself is in possession of one.
After some more murder, we find ourselves in Part IV, In the Vinkus. At the end of the previous section, Elphaba arrived at a mauntery (a convent) in a state of “dreamless, sleepless grief” and is welcomed by a decrepit old woman, mad Mother Yackle. Seven years later, it is time for Elphaba to finally leave the mauntery “to conduct an exercise in expiation”:
“You feel there is a penalty to pay before you may find peace. The unquestioning silence of the cloister is no longer what you need. You are returning to yourself.”
Elphaba joins a caravan headed into the Vinkus accompanied by Liir, a young boy raised among the orphans at the Cloister of Saint Glinda. They travel to Kiamo Ko, the seat of the royal family of the Arjiki, where Elphaba plans to seek forgiveness from Fiyero’s wife, Sarima. But Sarima will not hear of it:
“You want to throw down your burden, throw it down at my feet, or across my shoulders. You want perhaps to weep a little, to say good-bye, and then to leave…This is my home, I am a nominal Dowager Princess of Duckshit, but I have a right to hear and I have a right not to hear. Even to make a traveler feel better.”
There is more talk evil and good (“in folk memory evil always predates good”), and there is the question of who Liir’s parents are or were (I felt so bad for that little boy!) But Elphaba will not leave Kiamo Ko without being forgiven for what happened with her and Fiyero, and so she and Liir over time become part of the household and family. During this time, Munchkinland secedes from Oz.
In Part V, The Murder and its Afterlife, things have not been going well for Elphaba. Now her sister (who had come to be viewed as a religious tyrant) has been killed be a house falling from a tornado, and some foreign girl has the magic shoes that Nessarose had promised would be Elphaba’s if she were to predecease her. The Wizard and Elphaba each have something the other wants. There is more talk of Yackle, the Kumbric Witch of legend, the Clock of the Time Dragon, the Other Land, souls, good and evil, parentage. Who is in thrall to whom? And it all comes to a head in an ending we are familiar with from the Wizard of Oz, albeit through a different perspective than that told by the victor of the story.
What I didn’t love about this last part was that Elphaba here hardly seemed recognizable as the Elphaba in all the rest of the book. So I couldn’t really understand her motivations here. Some reviewers describe it as her descent into madness, so I guess that could explain it. But boy did I enjoy the journey getting to this point, and I think this book presented me with things I will be thinking about for a long time.
Maybe the definition of home is the place where you are never forgiven, so you may always belong there, bound by guilt. And maybe the cost of belonging is worth it.
I think I MUST read the sequel at some point, since people seem to say it answers some of the questions left by this book. I look forward to it!
People who hated this book seem to primarily have picked it up either under the belief that it would be like the Broadway musical, which it apparently isn’t (and now I’m wondering if I really want to see the movie version of the musical after all, since I loved the book so much and will probably be disappointed by how different the movie/musical is), or under the belief that it was a children’s book because the source material it is reimagining was for children. So be aware: the musical based off of this book apparently takes liberties and does not follow it precisely (this grim story also seemed like a very odd choice to turn into a musical, to me); and this story explaining everything that Elphaba went through to shape her into the Wicked Witch of the West painted as the villain is most certainly not for children.
Strange Beasts by Susan J. Morris is a 384 page novel published in 2024 by Bindery Books.
Genre:
Mystery, Gaslamp Fantasy
Opening Line:
Samantha Harker’s heels rang on the fine marble floors as she hurried past plaster reliefs of scenes torn from myth.
My Thoughts:
Are you interested in stories about government organizations dedicated to investigating supernatural phenomena? Are you curious what a partnership between the daughter of Mina and Jonathan Harker from Bram Stoker’s Dracula and the daughter of Professor Moriarty from the Sherlock Holmes series would look like? Did you like the idea of the bookish researcher (with an academic and personal interest in the occult, like Ninth House) taking to the field like in the Emily Wilde books? The possibility of a quasi-religious/political group being behind horrific beastly attacks like in The Brotherhood of the Wolf? The scheming to trap a potential werewolf at the opera like in Gabriel Knight: The Beast Within? Do you appreciate queer representation in the books you read, with a gentle romance arc that takes a backseat to the adventurous and mysterious plot? Do you like your feminist rage to have actual, literal bite?
If you said yes to any of the above, then do I have a treat for you!
In 1903, Sam and Hel are agents of the London Field Office of The Royal Society for the Study of Abnormal Phenomena. Ostensibly, the group hunts dangerous monsters of the paranormal variety. Our two heroines are sent to Paris to look into a spree of brutal murders thought to have been committed by some kind of Capital B Beast. Their investigation takes them to illicit salons, the catacombs, the opera, and many other places besides.
The two women must learn to trust one another, which does not come easy. Sam is used to keeping her ability as a channel secret, as most people believe this means she will inevitably fall under the sway of monsters and is therefore a danger herself. Conversely, everyone knows the identity of Hel’s father, but what they don’t know is that by making the choice to free herself from his influence, she guaranteed that he will always target people she gets close to.
My one complaint is that it seems like this book tried to be and do a little too much. There’s Sam channeling, false visions, a hidden rage, Jakob Van Helsing (son of Abraham) foiling her wherever she goes in a bid to save her from her own inexorable descent into monstrousness, the men in the Royal Society discounting the abilities of the women, personal agency, the question of monster versus victim, alchemy, religious and political motivations, the potential for Moriarty to be manipulating their investigation, covert ciphers, messages sent via bees…all on top the of the basic premise of uncovering who is responsible for the murders and stopping them.
(And one extremely niggling issue: I understand that “wills o’the wisp” is probably the proper plural form, but it still sounds off enough to kick me from the immersion in the story, and it is a term that gets used SO. MUCH.)
Even with being a bit extra, this is a 4.75 star book for me. I really liked the characters, the early twentieth century Paris setting, the paranormal elements, and the investigation into the Beast killings. It was a lot of fun, and I wasn’t bored for even a moment. It does leave the door open for another adventure to come. I will be keeping an eye on this author, and this publisher, for sure.
Thank you to NetGalley, Bindery Books, and Inky Phoenix Press for the eARC in exchange for my unbiased review.
A Grim Reaper’s Guide to Catching a Killer by Maxie Dara was published by Berkley in 2024, and is the first in the SCYTHE Mystery series, although this story works as a standalone.
Genre:
Mystery
Opening Line:
I tapped the address in my file with the lid of the pen I’d been chewing on.
My Thoughts
I took this delightful mystery in via audio (the narration was fantastic!)
Kathy works for a company called S.C.Y.T.H.E. as a collector–she goes to the scene of a death and transports the person’s soul to the appropriate location for processing into the afterlife. But the soul of 17 year old Conner convinces her he was murdered by someone in her organization. They must investigate what really happened and why it was covered up, all before Conner’s soul becomes fated to be stuck on Earth forever as a ghost. All this while 42 year old Kathy is going through a divorce and pregnant with her first child.
The mystery was all well and good, but it was the relationships that made this one so touching. Conner really felt a lack of love from his parents, and Kathy worries she will be a terrible parent. The two of them wind up helping each other out far beyond working together to save Conner from an eternity as a ghost. This found family aspect was so sweet!
The narrative style of this book is super amusing, and I let out some laughs here and there. The story definitely left me with some questions about details (what exactly does Kathy do at her cubicle in the office all day every day for a job as what amounts to a currier?) But it was sweet and funny enough that these things didn’t bother me overmuch. I really enjoyed this one!
House of Frank by Kay Synclaire is a standalone novel coming October 15th from Bindery Books.
Genre:
Cozy Fantasy, Romance, LGBTQIA+
Opening Line:
“Sing for me,” you whisper. “Please.”
My Thoughts:
3.5 stars for this is a cozy fantasy story with grieving as a major theme throughout, and an LGBTQIA+ romance.
Saika is a music witch mourning the death of her sister. Fiona made her promise to see that her ashes were planted at the arboretum at Ash Gardens, where they will grow into something beautiful. Even after she arrives at Ash Gardens, Saika finds she is not yet ready to part with her sister’s ashes, and she winds up staying on and helping out around the place. She gets to know the others employed there, including cherubs, an elf, a half-gargoyle, and a one-of-a-kind beast. It turns out they are all suffering their own losses, and develop relationships that allow them to help one another navigate through their grief.
This was nice story of love, loss, friendship, and healing. The range of characters was nice, although you only get to know a few of them beyond surface level. I wasn’t really feeling the romance between our two lovebirds, personally–their interactions with one another were more irritating than anything, in my opinion, but it made for a sweet story. This is a slower-paced character driven tale, and though it takes place in a fantasy world, we are only shown this one specific part of it at Ash Gardens (with one day trip into the city). Potential readers should also know the narration often veers into second person, as Saika addressing her departed sister. It’s not like the entire book is written in second person point of view, but some people may be turned off even by a portion of it being so.
Now if I may grumble a little bit – when Saika reads that a dragon laying eggs means it’s trying to start a family and explains this to others, and their response is, “I had no idea!’…what exactly was their understanding of how eggs work?! Also, this is another case of me being taken by surprise by the occasional F-word sprinkled throughout–cursing in books doesn’t bother me (as long as it’s not excessive), but was surprising in what otherwise seemed like such a wholesome story.
But overall this was a decent cozy, emotional yet hopeful read.
Thank you to Bindery Books and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my unbiased review.
A Sorceress Comes to Call by T. Kingfisher is a 336 page standalone novel published by Tor Books in 2024.
Genre:
Fantasy, Fairytale Retelling
Opening Line:
There was a fly walking on Cordelia’s hand and she was not allowed to flick it away.
After reading and adoring What Moves the Dead and A House with Good Bones, I adopted T. Kingfisher as one of my autobuy authors. Her newest novel, A Sorceress Comes to Call, is a reimaging of Goose Girl by the Brothers Grimm, with the inclusion of Kingfisher’s signature humor as well as some additional dark fantastical elements.
Fourteen-year-old Cordelia is the daughter of a ruthless, social-climbing sorceress. She is terrified of her mother, who not only permits her daughter no privacy, but goes so far as to frequently take control of her body. When she sets her sights on the Squire of Chatham and gets to work trying to procure a marriage proposal from him, Cordelia finds allies among his family, friends, and household staff. Can this group of unlikely heroes manage to best a wicked woman with immense power and a demonic familiar?
This is a grimly suspenseful story with great characters, and funny lines sprinkled throughout. This is not my favorite of this author’s work, but it’s still a decent showing. And it makes a beautiful shelf trophy!