The Lost Story by Meg Shaffer is a 352 portal world fantasy novel published by Ballantine Books in 2024.
Genre: Fantasy
Opening Line:
Once upon a time in West Virginia, two boys went missing.
Well this was just a lovely story!
Two teenage boys went missing in the woods for six months. Now as adults, Rafe has no memory of their time away. Jeremy does, but he’s not telling; what Jeremy DOES do is find missing people and things with seemingly supernatural ease.
Emilie wants to hire Jeremy to find the body of her sister who was kidnapped as a teen and has been missing ever since. What she finds instead is that what really happened to her sister has everything to do with what happened to Rafe and Jeremy all those years ago, and a magical fantasy kingdom a la C. S. Lewis’s Narnia.
These main characters were delightful! They’re funny and sympathetic and complex, and there is a nice LGBTQIA+ romance you find yourself rooting for from early on, before you even know for sure how the characters feel about one another.
The details of the fantasy kingdom are really pretty secondary to the story about the fact that this magical world exists, and how it came to exist. But I honestly didn’t mind that the nitty gritty of being in a fantasy world seemed rather phoned in, because the rest of these things were so wonderful. If I hugged books, this one would definitely be deserving!
Edited to add:
I initially wrote this post before I had devised my rating systems for sexual and violent content. I think I remember that the sexual content all happens off the page, and the only violence I recall is what Emilie imagines had happened to her sister when she went missing, and perhaps a dash of fantasy battling with evil creatures with swords and bows.
I also see now that the final version of this book includes a lovely little map of the fantasy kingdom of Shanadoah, a nice touch.
Jessica Crawford 