Battle of the Book Covers, May 2024 Edition

A bit late with this one, but better than never, eh? Here are the books I read in May that have differing US and UK covers.

The Morningside by Tea Obreht. They just switched the color…not saturation, I’m not positive of the term I’m looking for here, maybe you can help me out. But I do enjoy the yellow and green tints on the US version more than the straight up orange and blue. A very pretty combination!

The US and Japanese editions of The Full Moon Coffee Shop by Mai Mochizuki are very similar. Preference basically comes down to if you like your astrological signs or a caffeinated beverage better on your book cover. I suppose I like the Japanese version a bit better, although the coffee drink on the US one hints at the cozy nature of the story.

James by Perceval Everett. Both covers are decent, but I do quite like the UK version, and it gets my vote this time. The color scheme and the artwork style are both lovely!

These covers for How High We Go in the Dark by Sequoia Nagamatsu all stuck to a similar theme, but I think I like the US one best.

First Lie Wins by a Ashley Elston. The UK version seems a bit more appropriate to the contents of the story, but the US cover overall is more eye catching.

Opening Lines and Book Cover Battle, April 2024

Of the books I read in the month of April, only The Hunter by Tana French appears to have differing cover designs. Both are fine, but the burning tree image on the UK edition takes the dub this time around.

As for the opening lines of the books I read over the last month, have a gander at these:

Her text came in just before midnight.

The Bad Ones by Melissa Albert

There was a dead girl in my aunt’s bakery.

A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking by T. Kingfisher

Though there’s an industry built on telling you otherwise, there are few real joys to middle age.

Calypso by David Sedaris

At dusk sixteen-year-old Margaret Murphy sits down at a narrow rickety desk in room 127 at Little Ida’s Motor Lodge, eleven miles east of Niagara Falls, and begins to write her confession.

Poor Deer by Clare Oshetsky

Anna kicked off the annual Pace family vacation with a lie.

Diavola by Jennifer Thorne

Trey comes over the mountain carrying a broken chair.

The Hunter by Tana French

We must, by law, keep a record of the innocents we kill.

Scythe by Neal Shusterman

“We could just push them out of windows,” says Leonie.

Cut & Thirst by Margaret Atwood

The Bad One‘s opening line itself doesn’t do much for this reader, but is followed immediately by what that text message was, which is more of a hook.

A dead person in an unexpected place is always intriguing, but the first line of A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking also lets you know from the get go that the story will be equally dark, cozy, and amusing – an interesting mix!

The David Sedaris memoir likewise begins in a way that advertises the humorous nature of the book.

The opening of Poor Deer is great, setting the scene and immediately having the reader want to know more about what a sixteen year old could possibly be confessing.

Diavola starts right off divulging that it is a story about a vacation involving toxic family dynamics. The supernatural elements get introduced later, with the setting of Villa Taccola.

The first line of The Hunter, in my opinion, is very lackluster. It does nothing for me other than have me say, “Oh, Trey – I remember that character from The Searcher.”

Scythe pulls readers in from the beginning by getting them to wonder why innocents are being killed in a way that requires a record.

The opening line of Cut & Thirst also broadcasts the comical nature of the story, with someone genuinely suggesting defenestration. Now the reader wants to know who might wind up being pushed out of windows, and why.

Overall, this was a pretty good reading month for me. So far I am having success meeting my 2024 goal of reading books that are a better fit for me so that my average star rating at the end of the year will be higher. Even the books here that I didn’t love received no less than 3 stars from me. Not too shabby!

BOTBC February 2024

February was a slower reading month for me (at least compared to how much I have typically been reading this past year or so), and only one book I read appears to have different US and UK cover designs. That book was How to Solve Your Own Murder (Castle Knoll Files #1) by Kristen Perrin, with an upcoming publication date of March 26th (review to come!)

There is no contest with these two, I vastly prefer to US cover. The style and artwork, the colors, everything!

What are your thoughts? Is there something you like better about the UK edition?

BOTBC Part 3

Of the books I read last month, only two had alternate cover editions.

The Warm Hands of Ghosts by Katherine Arden, author of The Winternight Trilogy (The Bear and the Nightingale) is an upcoming historical fantasy novel set during World War I (expected publication February 13, 2024). I think I have to give call this one a tie – I like the US cover because it’s rather unique, but the colors of the UK one are just so darn pretty!

Mrs. Caliban, written by Rachel Ingalls and originally published in 1982, is an interesting novella about a lonely house wife and a frog man. The US covers win this round for me; I like the US hardcover edition best, but the paperback is certainly not without its charm.

And with that, on to a new year of reading!

Battle of the Book Covers (henceforth known as BOTBC) Part 2

Of the books I read in November, only a few have different US and UK book covers. Which do you prefer?

While the color scheme of the US book cover for Cara Hunter’s Murder in the Family is more eye-catching, the UK version seems more thematically appropriate to me, and gets my vote.

North Woods by Daniel Mason is one of my absolute favorite reads of the year – possibly even THE top read! That being said, no offense to the catamount, but I prefer the UK book cover.

The Kind Worth Killing by Peter Swanson has four different covers, one for both hardcover and paperback editions in the UK and US. Personally, the US paperback version speaks to me the most, but overall I kind of just feel “meh” about all of them.

The Battle of the Book Covers

I recently read Starve Acre by Andrew Michael Hurley, a book that had been on my TBR for some time. Apparently it’s being turned into a major motion picture, and the edition of the book I received when I ordered it earlier this year is the “media tie-in” version. I personally like both the original UK and US editions so much better than the one I wound up with! But this gave me an idea for a blog post, which is to say, let’s have a look at the UK and US editions of the covers of some of the books I’ve read this month.

If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio. I have to vote for the US cover here. Although, despite the fact that, as I said, I have had my eye on this book for a long time, never before did I notice the yellow lines over the middle of the 💀. Both the skull image and the font of the text appeal more to me in this version, as well as it’s cleaner, less cluttered look.

My Friend Anne Frank by Hannah Pick-Goslar (is “The Inspiring and Heartbreaking True Story of Best Friends Torn Apart and Reunited Against All Odds” the official subtitle for the US edition, but not the UK one?) Obviously both covers utilized the same original photo, but again I find the US version more eye-catching, with the image less washed out and the bolder color choice.

Pretty Girls by Karin Slaughter. Hmm, these might be a tie for me. Blue and green are my two favorite colors, and so the US version has that going for it. But the smears of blood on the UK cover really are a nice touch. A nice touch derived, as it is, from a very bad touch (be sure to look up content warnings for this book if there are certain topics you are especially sensitive to!)

Whale Fall by Elizabeth O’Conner has a publication date set for May 7, 2024, but I was able to read an ARC. Although the color (in all that empty space) of the UK edition is nice, the US is a clear winner for me again here. I just really dig the font and the fact that the text looks like it was painted by brush strokes. Additionally, it conveys a better sense of the harsh nature of the sea that is an integral part of the story.

So there you have it. Was I surprised that this was almost a clean sweep for the US? Yes! Is this a fluke for my October reading only? I don’t know—maybe I’ll do this again for my November reads, and we’ll see!

By the by, here are the original cover editions that got me on this kick.

Here is a final graphic showing all of the books I fit into the month. All were ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ or above for me, not a stinker in the bunch!