reading

Book Review: SALTWATER by Katy Hays

| Jessica Crawford

Saltwater: A Novel by Katy Hays is a 336 page standalone novel from Ballantine Books with a publish date of March 25, 2025.

Genre:

Thriller, Family Drama, Mystery

Opening Line

(After a news article regarding the death of a woman while vacationing with her wealthy family in 1992.)

Money is my phantom limb.

Synopsis:

In 1992 Sarah Lingate is found dead below the cliffs of Capri, leaving behind her three-year-old daughter, Helen. Despite suspicions that the old-money Lingates are involved, Sarah’s death is ruled an accident. And every year, the family returns to prove it’s true. But on the thirtieth anniversary of Sarah’s death, the Lingates arrive at the villa to find a surprise waiting for them—the necklace Sarah was wearing the night she died.

Haunted by the specter of that night, the legendary Lingate family unity is pushed to a breaking point, and Helen seizes the opportunity. Enlisting the help of Lorna Moreno, a family assistant, the two plot their escape from Helen’s paranoid, insular family. But when Lorna disappears and the investigation into Sarah’s death is reopened, Helen has to confront the fact that everyone who was on Capri thirty years ago remains a suspect—her controlling father Richard, rarely-lucid aunt Naomi, distant uncle Marcus, and their circle of friends, visitors, and staff. Even Lorna, her closest ally, may not be who she seems.

As long-hidden secrets about that night boil to surface, one thing becomes not everyone will leave the island alive.

My Thoughts:

Saltwater by Katy Hays is a tense and twisty thriller featuring family secrets and Rich People Behaving Badly, with a strong sense of place transporting the reader to the glistening shores and plummeting cliffsides of the Italian island of Capri.

The Lingate family is Old Money with a fixation on maintaining appearances, even when this means closing ranks when one of their own dies suspiciously. As an adult, Helen, the daughter of the deceased, just wants to live in the present, but her family seems tied down by the past. She would do anything to escape the bonds of her overly controlling family in order to experience true freedom for the first time in her life. Lorna is similarly ready to free herself from the life she is forced to live in the shadow of the rich and powerful. The two women plot together to free themselves from the unwanted constraints of the Lingates and other families like them.

This was a decent thriller with conspiring, betrayal, and murder, all set in enticing locales such as an Italian villa and on the waters of the Mediterranean Sea. Who can trust whom? One aspect of this story that didn’t work so great for me was that the chapters alternating amongst three timelines, but each occurring in the same locations with almost the exact same characters present, got confusing at times. “Okay, so this chapter picks back up with Helen on a boat with Ciro, but is this the time Freddy was there with them, or Lorna? Was this before or after that other event? I can’t remember!”

Things get a tad bit convoluted and farfetched as truths are revealed, but overall I enjoyed this bracing story of suspense.

There is sexual content in this story, but nothing that happens on the page. There is violence, but nothing super graphic.

Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Bookshop.org

Goodreads

Book Review: THE WARBLER by Sarah Beth Durst

| Jessica Crawford

The Warbler by Sarah Beth Durst is a 335 page standalone novel published March 1, 2025 by Lake Union Publishing of Amazon.

Genre:

Fantasy, Magical Realism

Opening Line:

My mother is a willow.

My Thoughts:

The newest novel from Sarah Beth Durst (author of The Spellshop) is magical realism about a young woman looking for answers about her family’s curse.

Her entire life, Elisa and her mother had to move from place to place, never calling a single place home, never leaving pieces of themselves behind or taking any mementos with them. For if they were to start to put roots down somewhere, they would begin to actually turn into trees themselves. This forces them into a nomadic lifestyle that requires them to appreciate each day for itself and to truly live in the moment, knowing that nothing will last. It’s not as easy life to grow up with, when everyone else around you seems to have much more stability and security, even if this means their lives are more predictable and less adventurous.

“Regrets aren’t a thing you can avoid,” Mom said. “They’re just a part of life. Every time you say yes, you’re saying no to a dozen other things you could be doing.”

Now, without her mother around anymore, Elisa chooses each destination based on her family’s history and whether or not she might learn about the origin of the curse, or the answer of how to break it. In this book she winds up in a quaint village with a bookstore complete with its very own resident cat, a stately old home with a porch hung with dozens of cages housing a diverse collection of birds, and a cafe frequented by three blue-haired old women who dispense cryptic wisdom. Could this be her final stop?

Chapters alternate telling Elisa’s story with those of her grandmother, Rose, and her mother, Lori. Each woman wants something different from life, and each faces obstacles in living the life that they want, either because of societal expectations, the consequences of actions (either their own, or someone else’s)…or because of the curse.

The pacing in this book does suffer at times, with the same points being driven home again and again; this occasionally wore on my patience. But overall I enjoyed this lovely and curious story.

Book Review: BLACK WOODS BLUE SKY by Eowyn Ivey

| Jessica Crawford

Black Woods Blue Sky by Eowyn Ivey (botanical illustrations by Ruth Hulbert) is a 306 page novel published in 2025 by Random House.

Genre:

Magical Realism, Literary Fiction

Opening Line:

Birdie knew her mistakes as soon as she cracked open her eyes.

Synopsis:

An unforgettable dark fairy tale that asks, Can love save us from ourselves?

Birdie’s keeping it together; of course she is. So she’s a little hungover sometimes, and she has to bring her daughter, Emaleen, to her job waiting tables at an Alaskan roadside lodge, but she’s getting by as a single mother in a tough town. Still, Birdie can remember happier times from her youth, when she was free in the wilds of nature.

Arthur Neilsen, a soft-spoken and scarred recluse who appears in town only at the change of seasons, brings Emaleen back to safety when she gets lost in the woods. Most people avoid him, but to Birdie he represents everything she’s ever longed for. She finds herself falling for Arthur and the land he knows so well. Against the warnings of those who care about them, Birdie and Emaleen move to his isolated cabin in the mountains on the far side of the Wolverine River.

It’s just the three of them in the vast black woods, far from roads, telephones, electricity, and outside contact, but Birdie believes she has come prepared. At first, it’s idyllic, but soon Birdie discovers that Arthur is something much more mysterious and dangerous than she could have imagined, and that like the Alaska wilderness, a fairy tale can be as dark as it is beautiful.

My Thoughts:

Oh, my heart! I loved this!

This story is saturated with love for the beauty and harshness of the Alaskan wilderness. It’s about 26 year old Birdie and her 6 year old daughter Emaleen scraping by at the Wolverine Lodge, where Birdie works as a server (and sometimes parties too much). Their paths cross with that of Arthur, an odd local man who only makes occasional appearances in town, as he lives up in the mountains on the other side of the river. In Arthur, Birdie sees the kind of life she wants – one closer to nature, away from societal pressures and vices. She and her daughter move out to his rustic cabin with him. But there’s something strange about Arthur…

It wasn’t the manic, head-spinning high she’d always chased. Instead, it was like she’s been kept in small box without any holes to let in the light or air, but now she’d climbed out and could fill her lungs with the fresh mountain breeze.

I liked all of the characters, even if they frustrated me at times. They are certainly not perfect. Birdie loves her daughter fiercely, but doesn’t always prioritize the right things.

Her mom knew how to do lots of things. She knew how to find blueberries and catch fish and shoot a gun, but Emaleen was worried that she didn’t know how to keep them safe.

The “dark fairytale” part of this story I think hammers home the idea that you can’t ask anyone, man or beast, to be better than their nature – you can’t even ask it of yourself.

“Peculiar how similar they are, the stories about bears. All down through the ages…Berserkers and shape-shifters. Wild sows taking in abandoned human babies and raising them as their own. Women falling in love with boars. Girls being abducted by bears and giving birth to their children in mountain caves. Russia, Europe, North America, Japan…Again and again. Did you know, there was a whole lines of Danes who believed they were the descendants of bears?”

“Have you ever seen one skinned out before?”
“What? Oh…a bear? Yeah, years ago. A black bear. When I was a kid. Grandpa Hank shot it on the homestead.”
“You remember what it looked like?”
“Like a person.”
“Exactly. The hands, the feet, the muscles in the legs and chest, you peel back that hide and it could be your brother under it all.

It was tempting, then, to draw a direct line from us to them, to forget the unfathomable void between a man’s moral judgment and a bear’s wild mind.

I spent most of this book liking it well enough, but the last 25% or so broke my heart in the way that some of my favorites do. A beautiful story!

It was bewildering, how closely grief ran alongside joy.

(Hot take version: if you like books about the beauty of Alaska but Kristin Hannah’s writing makes your eyes roll out of your head, and you wouldn’t mind a story that features women making stupid decisions in regards to bears but couldn’t stand the characters in Julia Phillips’ Bear, try this book instead!)

Goodreads

Book Review: THE WILL OF THE MANY by James Islington

| Jessica Crawford

The Will of the Many by James Islington is a 630 page novel that is the first in a planned series, Hierarchy. It was published by Saga Press in 2023.

Genre:

Fantasy

Synopsis:

At the elite Catenan Academy, a young fugitive uncovers layered mysteries and world-changing secrets in this new fantasy series by internationally bestselling author of The Licanius Trilogy, James Islington.

AUDI. VIDE. TACE.

The Catenan Republic – the Hierarchy – may rule the world now, but they do not know everything.

I tell them my name is Vis Telimus. I tell them I was orphaned after a tragic accident three years ago, and that good fortune alone has led to my acceptance into their most prestigious school. I tell them that once I graduate, I will gladly join the rest of civilised society in allowing my strength, my drive and my focus – what they call Will – to be leeched away and added to the power of those above me, as millions already do. As all must eventually do.

I tell them that I belong, and they believe me.

But the truth is that I have been sent to the Academy to find answers. To solve a murder. To search for an ancient weapon. To uncover secrets that may tear the Republic apart.

And that I will never, ever cede my Will to the empire that executed my family.

To survive, though, I will still have to rise through the Academy’s ranks. I will have to smile, and make friends, and pretend to be one of them and win. Because if I cannot, then those who want to control me, who know my real name, will no longer have any use for me.

And if the Hierarchy finds out who I truly am, they will kill me.

Opening Line:

I am dangling, and it is only my father’s blood-slicked grip around my wrist that stops me from falling.

My Thoughts:

This was quite good! Reminded me in some ways of Red Rising, but scaled a teensy bit more YA, and a tad of The Name of the Wind, but without the insufferable protagonist constantly singing his own praises as he recounts his past. (To be fair, our man Vis is pretty much the best at everything he tries in this story, but that can be explained by the fact that he received a top notch education beginning early in life, and trains his buns off within these pages).

There is a Roman-inspired republic (AKA Evil Empire) taking over the world, dividing all of its citizens into a hierarchy in which the lower castes must cede their very will to their betters, granting the latter superhuman abilities. Vis is a teenager trying to survive in this new society after it demolished his old one. He winds up being sent to a school for the youth of the republic’s elite in an effort to send him in to infiltrate a very secure location and uncover its secrets. There was good world building and political machinations, both within the school setting as well as on the world stage.

This is a long book, and though it’s not necessarily longwinded or bogged down with extraneous material, it certainly could have been trimmed a bit in some areas. Additionally, it’s hinted at all along that there is going to be some mind blowing revelation of something with which most people in this world are unaware, and I was disappointed that the end only confirms this without actually explaining it yet, leaving readers with no actual answers to the questions we’ve been asking all along. Everything the story had been dangling in front of us from the start was left dangling. But still, I mostly enjoyed the journey and remain intrigued enough that I will likely pick up book 2 at some point, and it may even prove to be one of those sequels that improves upon its predecessor by bringing the story to an even bigger scale.

4.5 stars!

Book Review: BROKEN COUNTRY by Clare Leslie Hall

| Jessica Crawford

Broken Country by Clare Leslie Hall is a 320 page standalone novel published in 2025 by Simon & Schuster.

Genre:

Literary Fiction

Subgenres:

Romance, Suspense

Opening Line:

The farmer is dead, he is dead and all anyone wants to know is who killed him.

My Thoughts:

4.5 stars

This is an emotional story following Beth, a young woman in North Dorset, England. Chapters alternate between timelines, one in 1955 when teenaged Beth meets and falls in love with Gabriel Wolfe, and one in 1968 when she is married to a farmer named Frank Johnson. Interspersed are also chapters showcasing a murder trial occurring after the other timelines, although who is on trial for whose murder is not made clear until near the end.

There is a touching story here about relationships before and after the loss of a child, both broken relationships and healing ones. A love of the natural world is on display in the writing. I found the parts describing infidelity difficult to read, but everyone at least winds up addressing their wrongdoings. Beth’s complicated feelings and the looming murder we know is going to happen create a tense atmosphere set against the simple pleasures of the pastoral setting and the love for a child.

Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for the eARC of this moving story in exchange for my unbiased review.

CW: death of a child, infidelity

Book Review: THE MERCY OF GODS by James S.A. Corey

| Jessica Crawford

The Mercy of Gods by James S.A. Corey is a 423 page novel published by Orbit of Hatchette Book Group published in 2024, and is Book One of the Captive’s War, a planned trilogy that will also feature additional novellas in between main installments. Like the author’s previous series, The Expanse, this work has also already been confirmed to be in the works as a television adaptation.

Genre:

Science Fiction

Synopsis:

A spectacular new space opera that sees humanity fighting for its survival in a war as old as the universe itself.

How humanity came to the planet called Anjiin is lost in the fog of history, but that history is about to end. The Carryx – part empire, part hive – have waged wars of conquest for centuries, destroying or enslaving species across the galaxy.  Now, they are facing a great and deathless enemy. The key to their survival may rest with the humans of Anjiin.   Caught up in academic intrigue and affairs of the heart, Dafyd Alkhor is pleased just to be an assistant to a brilliant scientist and his celebrated research team.  Then the Carryx ships descend, decimating the human population and taking the best and brightest of Anjiin society away to serve on the Carryx homeworld, and Dafyd is swept along with them. They are dropped in the middle of a struggle they barely understand, set in a competition against the other captive species with extinction as the price of failure.  Only Dafyd and a handful of his companions see past the Darwinian contest to the deeper game that they must play to learning to understand – and manipulate – the Carryx themselves. With a noble but suicidal human rebellion on one hand and strange and murderous enemies on the other, the team pays a terrible price to become the trusted servants of their new rulers. Dafyd Alkhor is a simple man swept up in events that are beyond his control and more vast than his imagination.  He will become the champion of humanity and its betrayer, the most hated man in history and the guardian of his people. This is where his story begins.

First Line:

You ask how many ages had the Carryx been fighting the long war?

My Thoughts:

“I think some important scientific questions have finally been answered. Alien life exists, and they are assholes.”

I’ve only read one other James S.A. Corey book, the first in The Expanse series, Leviathan Wakes. Looking back at my review, it seems I thought that one started and ended with a bang, but was a real slog in between. In contrast, this book was much more consistent throughout.

I did watch The Expanse TV show and loved it. In many ways, The Mercy of Gods felt reminded me of that other series: humanity laboring to learn about a previously unknown alien threat.

If they survived this alien hellscape, it would be because of this. Because in the face of trauma and violence, what they wanted first was to know, to understand.

In the far future, an alien race called the Carryx has made a habit of conquering other worlds and assimilating its native intelligent species, IF said species can prove themselves useful to their new overlords. Otherwise, they get culled. Humanity has now fallen into the clutches of this merciless intergalactic empire. Can they prove their worth? Should they revolt, even knowing it’s a death sentence? In the meantime, the reader is aware that there is another race if aliens locked in a generations-long war with the Carryx, and maybe they might be the ones to finally topple the tyrants.

The characters are a collection of humans the Carryx found most likely to be useful – top tier scientists and scholars, for example. There is the young research assistant who knows how to read other people and act in a way to set them at ease; the man who irritates his fellows by defaulting to making jokes in times of stress (mentioned to be gay, although this aspect of does not come into play in this part of the story); the researcher whose suicidal ideation comes flooding back once she runs out of her routine medication as a prisoner. This work group serves as this book’s version of the crew of the Rocinante, and while I wasn’t overly fond of or super connected to any of them, I didn’t actively dislike any of them like I did in Leviathan Wakes (I enjoyed the characters as they were portrayed on the TV show MUCH more!)

“Stop sciencing all over my story,” Jellit said. “The fact is that it worked.”

Overall this was an interesting story, with a lot of intriguing ideas and a sense of tension carrying it forward. But I am disappointed that this is a case of Book One of the series offering zero resolution of any kind. Obviously I expected the overarching story to continue, but often each installment in a series has a more focused arc that meets with some kind of resolution, but not so here. If I do read on, it will have to be with the understanding that the next book while likely also leave me feeling this way, waiting until the end of book three to feel any satisfaction whatsoever. I might be willing to do that, but honestly, since it’s already been announced this series is being turned into another television show, I am more likely to just wait to watch that.

Book Review: THE SAFEKEEP by Yael van der Wouden

| Jessica Crawford

The Safekeep by Yael van der Wouden is a 272 page standalone novel published byAvid Reader Press of Simon & Schuster in 2024, and was shortlisted for the Booker Prize 2024.

Genre:

Historical fiction, literary fiction

Synopsis:

An exhilarating, twisted tale of desire, suspicion and obsession between two women staying in the same house in the Dutch countryside during the summer of 1961-a powerful exploration of the legacy of WWII and the darker parts of our collective past.

A house is a precious thing…it is 1961 and the rural Dutch province of Overijssel is quiet. Bomb craters have been filled, buildings reconstructed, and the war is truly over. Living alone in her late mother’s country home, Isabel knows her life is as it should be—led by routing and discipline. But all is upended when her brother Louis brings his graceless new girlfriend Eva, leaving her at Isabel’s doorstep as a guest, to stay for the season. Eva is Isabel’s antithesis: she sleeps late, walks loudly through the house, and touches things she shouldn’t. In response, Isabels develops a fury-fueled obsession, and when things start disappearing around the house—a spoon, a knife, a bowl—Isabel’s suspicions begin to spiral. In the sweltering peak of summer, Isabel’s paranoia gives way to infatuation—leading to a discovery that unravels all Isabella has ever known. The was might not be well and truly over after all, and neither Eva—nor the house in which they live—are what they seem.

Mysterious, sophisticated, sensual, and infused with intrigue, atmosphere, and sex, The Safekeep is a brilliantly plotted and provocative debut novel you won’t soon forget.

Opening Line:

Isabel found a broken piece of ceramic under the roots of a dead gourd.

My Thoughts:

She had made the kitchen a lovely place. Isabel could cry at it: at how a room could be made, and left behind, and turn terrible by way of absence. How a space could miss a person. How a person could stop–

This book is literary historical fiction set in the Netherlands in 1961, with references to the years of World War II. I was digging it at first, but then wound up getting really bored by it for a while, as plot advancement stalls and we are treated to many, many pages of the main character just being angry and hateful. Things then take a turn and get quite spicy for Isabel (who seems to be portrayed as on the autism spectrum, as well as with some OCD/paranoia/anxiety stemming from the wartime).

Eva said this often: You know what I mean, and Isabel mostly never knew what she meant, not exactly. Only that Eva was frightened and that she saw people as danger. Isabel understood fear. Isabel rarely considered other people at all.

The romance aspect of the story was certainly not boring, but was portrayed in a way I found quite awkward and uncomfortable (there was a whole lot of “pushing” and “pulling” going on in the love scenes, and I understand why these terms might be used once for an affair in which the lovers don’t want to want each other, but these sentiments were a bit overused).

About two thirds of the way in, reading a non-POV character’s diary really flips things around with some magnificent revelations that blew me away. But unfortunately by the end I was bored again.

The writing on the sentence-level overall was good, certainly, but I did get tired with the stilted nature of the prose (a lot of sentences and thoughts and dialogue cut off midway without being completed).

Although I was predominantly underwhelmed by this book, the payoff from reading the diary entries alone was worth it. It will have you seething about man’s inhumanity to man, as it unveils some experiences of being a Dutch Jew in and around the time of the Holocaust.

Book Review: THE FAVORITES by Layne Fargo

| Jessica Crawford

The Favorites by Layne Fargo is a 448 page standalone novel published by Random House in 2025.

Genre:

Contemporary Fiction, Retelling

Opening Line:

Today is the tenth anniversary of the worst day of my life.

My Thoughts:

Guys, I think I already read one of my top ten books of 2025.

When I was strong and self-assured, people recoiled from me. They told me I was too competitive, too ambitious, too much. But when I was brought low, bruised and bleeding, a princess in need of rescue instead of a conquering queen, they loved me.

This book is a reimagining of Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights with modern competitive ice dancers, and I was absolutely addicted to it! I did enjoy Wuthering Heights, although it boggles my mind that people call it a romance. I consider it a pure revenge story, and for whatever reason, I really seem to dig the revenge stories (that one, The Count of Monte Cristo, The Stars my Destination.) Although The Favorites has revenge, it is definitely more of a love story, albeit one that is a bit toxic at times.

At first I thought the comp of this book to the classic just meant it was inspired by it and had many of the same themes, but it’s more than that. Our characters are Heath Rocha (Heathcliff), Katarina Shaw (Catherine Earnshaw), Lee Shaw (Hindley Earnshaw), Isabella Lin (Isabella Linton), and Garret Lin (Edgar Linton). There are similarities to the story arc, but it is definitely not an exact copy in a new setting.

Kat has long idolized Olympic gold medalist Sheila Lin, and wishes fervently to follow in her footsteps to become a champion ice dancer. Because this is what she wants, Heath learns to be her ice dance partner. The two have been skating together since children, and in love with each other almost as long. The rub is that Kat is the most important thing in the world to Heath, and while Kat loves Heath like crazy, becoming champion is the most important thing to her.

They wind up presented with the amazing opportunity to train with Sheila Lin herself at Lin Academy. There they work alongside Sheila’s twin children, Garrett and Bella. The Lins are wealthy and entitled, and Heath can’t say he loves the way Kat changes when she’s around them and training at such a prestigious facility.

I really liked the best frenemy situation between Kat and Bella. They become friends, but both are incredibly ambitious and have the same goal, so they use one another as motivation to always push to improve and best the other. Even as competitors, the way they understand one another is a strong glue binding them.

“Any bitch can get married, but-“
“It takes a special bitch to be national champion?”
“Exactly.”

Interspersed between some chapters are transcripts from the documentary that commemorates the ten year anniversary of what Kat calls the worst day of her life, while the rest of the book is written in Kat’s POV, first person past tense. This style was great, it added a lot.

Kat and Heath realize the public respond more to their romance story as skate partners than they do to their performances as elite athletes, and decide to play it up for the press. Some in the industry consider them something of a scandal. Through it all, Heath’s number one goal in life is to be enough for the woman he loves, while Kat doesn’t take her eyes off the prize of taking home the Olympic gold. Unsurprisingly, some of the other hopefuls don’t shy away from trying to sabotage rival teams.

The characters in this book just all felt so real to me, multilayered, not 100% good or bad throughout. I loved taking this wild ride with them.

And as a side note, I also really enjoy the playlist the author put together for this book. Usually I avoid those, because although authors say it’s music that inspired them while writing, I can like the book and yet still not share their taste in music. In this case I took a look at the playlist because so many songs are mentioned in the book as the pieces the ice dancers are performing to. And it turns out this extra long playlist has many, many songs I am loving and would never have otherwise found on my own.

All the stars for this book, which had a 41 year old woman who doesn’t dance and hates being the center of attention asking, “Is it too late for me to start training in ice dance?” It did seem a bit overlong, but as I wanted to live in its pages forever, that didn’t bother me. I would love to see this as a movie some day!

People seem to have a strong preference for either the US or UK version of the book cover. How do you feel about them?

Book Review: THOSE FATAL FLOWERS by Shannon Ives

| Jessica Crawford

Those Fatal Flowers by Shannon Ives is a 384 page standalone novel from Dell of Ballantine Books with a publish date of January 21, 2025.

Genre/Subgenres:

Mythology Retelling, Historical Fiction, Romance

Opening Line:

The night before Ceres’ palace becomes a tomb, it’s halls are filled with music.

Synopsis:

Greco-Roman mythology and the mystery of the vanished Roanoke colony collide in this epic adventure filled with sapphic longing and female rage—a debut novel for fans of Madeline Miller, Jennifer Saint, and Natalie Haynes.Before, Scopuli. 

It has been centuries since Thelia made the mistake that cost her the woman she loved. As the handmaidens charged with protecting Proserpina, the goddess of spring, Thelia and her sisters are banished to the island of Scopuli, cursed to live as sirens—winged half-woman, half-bird creatures. In luring men to their death, they hope to gain favor from the gods who could free them. But then ships stop coming and Thelia fears a fate worse than the underworld. Just as time begins to run out, a voice emerges, Proserpina’s voice; and what she asks of Thelia will spark a daring and dangerous quest for freedom.

Now, Roanoke. 

Thelia can’t bear to reflect on her last moments in Scopuli, where she left behind her sisters. After weeks drifting at sea, Thelia’s renewed human body is close to death. Luckily, an unfamiliar island appears on the horizon—Roanoke. Posing as a princess arriving on a sailboat filled with riches, Thelia infiltrates the small English colony. It doesn’t take long for her to realize that this place is dangerous, especially for women. As she grows closer to a beautiful settler who mysteriously resembles her former love, Thelia formulates a plan to save her sisters and enact revenge on the violent men she’s come to hate. But is she willing to go back to Scopuli and face the decisions of her past? And will Proserpina forgive her for all that she’s done?Told in alternating timelines, Those Fatal Flowers is a powerful, passionate, and wildly cathartic love letter to femininity and the monstrous power within us all.

My Thoughts:

What happens when you mix a mystery from America’s history with mythology, feminist rage, and romance?

This book right here.

It presents an interesting case: what if sirens from Greco-Roman mythology were responsible for the disappearance of the inhabitants of the lost colony of Roanoke? The author explains that her aim with this story was to explore the effects of loss and guilt on the psyche while also examining structural violence. It does a fair job in this endeavor, while also including a sapphic love story.

Our main character is Thelia, one of three sisters who acted as handmaidens to Proserpina (Persephone), and who were transformed into winged creatures to assist in the search for their charge when she was abducted by Dis (Hades). When they fail to find and rescue the goddess, they are imprisoned on an island as punishment. There, they lure sailors with their singing. (This book alternately refers to them as harpies and sirens, but I think the singing and luring part indicates they were just sirens, not harpies?)

After centuries have gone by, Thelia learns there may be a way to lift the curse she and her sisters are under, but it requires the sacrifice of many treacherous men…something the English colony of Roanoke in the Americas has more then a few of.

I liked the unique premise of the story and the bits detailing the lives of Thelia and her sister sirens on the island of Scopuli, and the writing on the sentence level was good.

On the other hand, I questioned the reliability of the behavior and speech of the Puritans depicted here. The men and women of Raleigh drank an awful lot of alcohol in this book, and said things like, “Fun little secret for you, my lady” before revealing some bit of gossip. I’m no scholar of history, but these things didn’t seem right to me. And I just wasn’t much feeling the romance — it was a bit of instalove on Thelia’s side (although in part because the object of her affections apparently looks so much like her long lost love that for a time she is trying to determine if it might actually BE her); and also, when on a timed mission for redemption, shouldn’t a centuries old divinity be able to keep it in her skirts?

All the hate for anything male really bothered me, BUT this does get addressed later on in the book, as Thelia finally learns that “monsters are made, not born”.

So while this book wasn’t a home run for me, it was decent and presents some intriguing concepts. If I were allowed half or even quarter star ratings, I’d say this was a 3.25 or 3.5 read for me.

Thank you the NetGalley and Dell/Penguin Random House for the eARC in exchange for my honest review!

Bookshop.org

Goodreads